Peach and Horne (1880)

Hoppe (1965)

Mykura (1976)

Flinn (1983)

Ross (1996)

ice front 

styles of glaciation

scandinavia 

scandinavian glaciation?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A Norwegian perspective - ice extent (yellow) at the LGM, with bathymetry and the flow lines of an ice stream in the Norwegian Trough. Shetland ice is regarded as contiguous with ice on the bed of the northern North Sea (Clark et al, 2004)

 

 

Ice flow models for Shetland

"One of the most interesting problems connected with glacial geology is the explanation of the glaciation of those groups of islands which lie at some distance from the north-east corner of the mainland of Scotland"         Ben Peach 1879

Ice limits off northern Scotland during and after the Last Glacial Maximum according to Hall et al. (2003)

Evidence of patterns of former ice flow on Shetland is largely confined to the present land area, including the key peripheral islands of Foula and Fair Isle. Ice flow lines have been reconstructed mainly from striae observations, together with data from stoss and lee features on ice-moulded bedrock, and provenance studies of surface erratics and the clastic component of tills.

A number of models of glacier flow have been developed. In some parts of Shetland, such as the Walls peninsula, these models show broadly similar patterns of flow. In many areas however there are significant differences between the models, a situation which reflects the limited number of observations, possible misinterpretation of ice directional indicators and the complexity of ice flow patterns through time.

The first detailed study of glaciation on Shetland was the pioneering work of Peach and Horne (1880). During their annual leave these ground-breaking geologists took a busman's holiday to Shetland. They quickly
identified two phases of glaciation. In the initial phase, the islands were thought to have been engulfed by ice of Scandinavian origin, with diversion of flow to the north-west by a confluent Scottish ice sheet. Later, during deglaciation, ice flowed radially from Shetland. Peach and Horne reported numerous valley "moraine heaps", for example at Swining and Collafirth Voes. Subsequent authors treated these as retreat or readvance features from local glaciation. The concept of Scandinavian glaciation later received support from the discovery of the tönsbergite erratic, apparently glacially transported from southern Norway, at Dalsetter. Home (1881), however, fiercely criticised Peach and Horne's mapping of striae on the east side of Shetland, noting that the sense of the direction of ice flow was towards the North Sea, rather than away from it.

Nearly a century later Hoppe (1965) provided a fundamentally different model of ice flow. In eastern Shetland many of Peach and Horne’s interpretations of ice flow directions, based on striae and ice-moulding observations, were reversed. The resultant model showed a dominantly radial flow from a local ice cap. Older sets of striae were noted, for example on Bressay which showed movement from the north-east and possibly suggested Scandinavian glaciation. Hoppe maintained that Shetland had been originally glaciated by Scandinavian ice and that the local icecap was a climatically inactive remnant of this ice sheet. Most of the observed striae were formed during a two-phase deglacial process: rapid open-water ice calving associated with the retreat of Scandinavian ice, and melting of the local ice cap. Diverging striae, such as those on North Roe and Walls, or striae that did not conform to the regional pattern, such as at Esha Ness, were accommodated by the shift between these two phases of deglaciation.

Mykura (1976) provided additional information for radial flow from an ice cap over central Shetland. To account for westward carry of erratics on Unst, Mykura suggested that Scandinavian ice lay just east of Shetland and either flowed across the area directly or diverted the flow of Shetland ice to recurve to the north and west. Westward erratic carry in southern Mainland was attributed directly to Scandinavian ice. The resultant ice flow lines look unrealistic for a single phase of ice floe in northern Shetland. Mykura added further evidence for fluctuating directions of ice flow in many parts of Shetland but he considered that retreat to Scandinavian ice allowed climatically active expansion of the local ice cap. He noted that there were clear signs of eastward flowing ice in southern Mainland, where there was also evidence of earlier westward carry. Mykura was not able to determine however if this later expansion of local ice covered Unst and Yell.

Flinn in a sequence of papers has provided important observations of the local glacial record on islands from Foula to Fair Isle and extended his investigations offshore to explore the evidence on the bed of the North Sea. Flinn (1983) identified an ice shed stretching almost the length of the islands from a local ice cap which did not cover the northern tip of Unst. His former arguments in favour of Scandinavian ice offshore at this time were rejected, and divergent ice flow patterns on Shetland were seen instead as a result of the influence of sea bed topography. With existing, but later refuted evidence from the northern North Sea that Scandinavian ice did not cross the Norwegian trench in the Late Devensian, Flinn concluded that any glaciation of Shetland by Scandinavian ice must have predated the last glaciation. The presence of meltwater channels, glaciofluvial sands and gravels, a proglacial lake and periglacial slope deposits in North Unst and Yell might be relate to deglaciation, but Flinn suggested that the absence of till and striae in these areas is indicative of an ice margin just to the north. Long and Skinner (1985) provided some support for Flinn's ice limit on Unst from till distribution on the adjacent seabed. Consideration however of the equivalent drift limit which seems to extend 75 kilometres east of Shetland produces an implausible ice sheet configuration.

Ross (1996) reviewed existing data and added new observations from offshore to provide a model of fluctuating ice margins during the Late Devensian. Off eastern Shetland, the ice margin at the glacial maximum is indicated by the limit of brown glacial deposits sourced from Shetland and lay around 100 km SE of Out Skerries (Peacock, 1995). To the west ice reached the continental shelf. As the ice margin retreated, the ice shed shifted, creating complex patterns of ice flow as the underlying topography began to exert a progressively greater influence on ice flow.

The ice margins east and west of Shetland demonstrate that the last ice cap was large, around 150 km across. The ice shed shifted over time but its average position is indicated as resting over the spine of the islands, as envisaged by Flinn, and corresponds with a zone of relatively limited erosion with restricted signs of ice roughening. The manner in which metamorphic erratics extend high on Ronas Hill requires not only that the ice shed lay to the east but it was significantly higher than this summit (450 m), as ice had to be driven uphill. Foula has ice moulding and erratics extending to at least 200m and there is no clear sign that these hills stood as nunataks above the last ice sheet (Flinn, 1978). Adopting the 'fried egg' shape of the ice sheet profile from northern Scotland (Ballantyne  et al, 1998), with steep ice surface slopes over the rigid hard rock beds on Shetland and gentler surface slopes on the soft, deformable beds of the North Sea and North Atlantic, implies that the ice surface stood at around 500-800 m in the ice shed zone over central Shetland.

Research work on the glaciation of Shetland is set to accelerate as the importance of understanding the glacial history of the islands is recognised for reconstructions of ice sheet dynamics in the Norwegian Channel, north North Sea and the West Shetland Platform. The latest models of the Scottish ice sheet developed by Hubbard in Aberystwyth show a thin, cold-based ice mass over Shetland, a picture that is at odds with the widespread evidence of glacial erosion across the islands. Perhaps Shetland received more snowfall? Davison and Stoker at BGS Edinburgh are working across the sea bed from St Magnus Bed to the shelf edge, identifying a series of moraine ridges related to the maximum limit and decay of the last ice cap on Shetland.


An important new paper has appeared recently from the Geological Survey on the last ice sheet in Shetland. Golledge et al. (2008) provide evidence from digital terrain models for an early phase of glacial streamlining that extends generally east to west across the entire island chain. This streamlining requires the former rapid flow of wet-based erosive ice from east of Shetland. Was this Scandinavian ice or did the ice shed in the Shetland ice cap once lie east of the islands? - the hunt is still on for evidence of ice moving out of the North Sea.